Murgatroyd and Mabel were butterflies. That is to say, Mabel was a butterfly, but Murgatroyd was still a caterpillar, in a way. They had both been caterpillars once. Murgatroyd had been a sort of spring green in color, with bright orange spots. Mabel had been covered with soft brown fur, and she had two pretty yellow tufts on her head, like a hat.
Then, one day, Murgatroyd and Mabel had spun their cocoons, and when they came out Mabel had worn two lovely lavender wings on her slender pink body. But when he came out, Murgatroyd looked just the same as before. He still looked like a caterpillar, except for one thing. Instead of growing wings, Murgratroyd had grown a propeller on his nose.
Murgatroyd could fly very fast with his propeller, and he could do loops and other tricks. "I wish I could fly like that," Mabel told him, and that made him happy. As Mabel would flutter by, Murgatroyd did barrel rolls and loop-the-loops around her so that they could get where they were going at the same time.
But one day as Murgatroyd and Mabel were sitting on a green twig in an apple tree he said to his friend, "Mabel, I think I'd like to try again."
Mabel was quite puzzled. "What do you mean?" she asked him, waving her wings delicately in the summer breeze.
Murgatroyd spun his propeller a little bit. "I'd like to try to grow wings again," he said.
"Oh, I see," Mabel said. "But you fly very well. Why would you want to do that?"
"Just to see if I can do it," Murgatroyd replied.
"You'll have to spin another cocoon, then," Mabel said.
"That's just what I had in mind," Murgatroyd said, and then and there he began to spin a new cocoon on the apple tree twig. Mabel sat and watched, and when he was through he poked his head out of the door of his cocoon and said, "I'll see you in eleven days."
"I'll be waiting," Mabel said, and Murgatroyd closed the door.
The sun rose and set ten times, and ten days passed, but there was hardly a sound in the apple tree except when a robin perched near the cocoons to look out over the green fields. On the eleventh day, though, something began to happen to the cocoon. Slowly, slowly, the door opened, but it was so dark inside that Mabel could see nothing at all.
Then, at last, Murgatroyd came out â only, he didn't look exactly as Mabel remembered. When he had come all the way out and stood on the apple tree twig Mabel said, "Oh, Murgatroyd! It didn't work! And, and...."
Murgatroyd looked down the length of his body, but it seemed to be just as it had been before he went into the cocoon. He looked at Mabel and said, "And what?"
Mabel felt very sad. "And you've even lost your propeller. Now you won't be able to fly at all."
Murgatroyd crossed his eyes to look at his nose, and, sure enough, the propeller was gone! "Oh, no!" he said. "I should have left well enough alone!" He was so dejected that he forgot to hold on to the twig, and he fell off.
"Murgatroyd!" Mabel cried, but there was nothing she could do. He was heading for the ground lickety-split. Then, suddenly, something happened. There was a roar, a blast of flame, and just as he was about to hit the ground Murgatroyd began to climb into the sky leaving a vapor trail behind him.
Mabel watched as her friend roared through the branches of the apple tree and disappeared into the sun, and she was still watching when Murgatroyd reappeared in a flash and settled onto the twig beside her.
"What was that?" she asked him.
"Look at me again," Murgatroyd said. "Don't you see?"
Mabel looked at him very closely, and then she saw it â Murgatroyd had lost his propeller, and he hadn't grown wings, but he had grown a jet pod instead!
"Oh, Murgatroyd," Mabel laughed, fluttering her lavender wings as she flew away from the apple twig. "You're twice as fast as you were before!" But Murgatroyd had no time to answer, for it was all he could do to shout "Whee!" as he did power dives and triple barrel rolls around her in the sweet summer air.

From The Book of Dialogue, How to Write Effective Conversation in Fiction, Screenplays, Drama, and Poetry, Hanover NH: University Press of New England, copyright © 2004 by Lewis Turco. All rights reserved.
NOTE: The original installment of this story, Murgatroyd and Mabel, with full color illustrations by Robert Michaels, published in 1978 by the Mathom Publishing Company, is still available at $9.95, shipping included, from the author, Wesli Court, at P. O. Box 161, Dresden ME 04342-0161.
Recent Comments